My experience with Multiculturalism
Schools in Western Sydney have a high proportion of
students from foreign language backgrounds. Such environments are considered to
be micropublic, a space where engagement and negotiation across cultures are
unavoidable, as individuals from diverse cultures find themselves having to
share a common social space (Ho, 2011). I personally went to a partially selective
public school, which had a very multicultural environment, thus I was considered to be in a micropublic space. Having a diverse
environment enabled me to have friendships with others of different cultural
backgrounds. Australia, being a multicultural environment, will
require its citizens to be able to interact with others of different cultural
backgrounds.
An example of a school that is a micropublic is Bankstown
Public School. 99.1% of students at this school have a language background
other than English, the highest in the state. Bankstown Public School Principal
Greg Mason comments, “(schools) a place of great opportunity. It’s fantastic
what these kids achieve, and always against a backdrop of tolerance and a very
global feeling”. With the world being so global, it is imperative that its
citizens are able to interact with a wide variety of people from diverse
cultural backgrounds. There are “new demands” (Ho, 2011), one being “the need
to nurture an appreciation of and respect for social, cultural and religious
diversity and sense of global citizenship”. My peers and I, being exposed to
different cultural groups, appreciated and embraced the variety of cultures we
had within our group. Many people believe that a multicultural school is better
learning environment, with Stephan Kerkyashrian, chairman of the Community
Relations Commission and formerly a long serving member of the NSW Board of
Studies stating, “With that multiplicity of culture and languages, the students
find their learning environment is broadened, their horizons are widened, they
can be exposed to so much more stimulation,”. Though there are many advantages
of students being in culturally diverse schools, there is a growing demand in
the private sector, “many elite schools have long waiting lists with some
parents enrolling their children at birth (Ho, 2011). I have personally engaged
students from private schools during my high school career and also at
university. Whilst most of them display respect for me and everyone with
different cultural groups than their own, I have found that a small population
of these students have a different attitude to everyone else around them. I
have seen an incredible level of arrogance being displayed by some who believe
that they are superior to other because they went to a private school. These students
exemplify those who are not meeting the “new demands” of appreciating others
from different social, cultural and religious backgrounds.
On the other hand, some Experts are arguing that schools
with large multicultural populations will not fare so well academically. Dr Bob
Birrell, population expert at Monash University states, “The problem is they
have many students who may need extra assistance, which diverts resources, and that
will have an overall impact on the performance of the school,”. This would be a
significant factor that influences the decision that parents make when choosing
which school to send their child to. According to the My Schools Website,
public schools have the highest percentage of students from languages
backgrounds other than English, with independent schools having the lowest
percentage and catholic schools falling in between. According to PISA 2009,
students from independent schools outperform their counterparts from public
schools significantly in all academic areas. Parents continue to value
academics above all else, viewing pirvate schools as "more discipline, values based and better resourced (Ho, 2011). Even for me, my parents, who were migrants from china
and thus exposed to the East Asian Schooling System, focused strongly on
academics and prioritised that above all else.
Though public schools are known from its great cultural
diversity, will it be a factor that parents take into account when deciding
which school to send their child to? Will parents value micropublics and
embrace the notion of globalisation for their children? I feel that most
parents only want to reap the academic benefits for their children. I believe
that it is important to have children engage prolifically in terms of social,
cultural and religious diversity to develop a sense of global citizenship. With my experiences at a multicultural school, I felt that I was able to develop a sense of respect for all those around me despite the difference in socially, culturally and religiously.
References
May 15, 2011, 1600 students, 69 languages, one school, Sydney Morning Herald, retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/national/education/1600-students-69-languages-one-school-20110514-1enb1.html
Ho, C. (2011). Respecting the presence of others: School
micropublics and everyday multiculturalism. Journal
of Intercultural Studies, 32(6), 603-619.
I found the content of this blog very interesting, expecially the point regarding to public and private schools. In my blog I mentioned that one of the advantages of public schools is that students get to experience a more diversed environment and meet people from more diversed backgrounds. However reading your blog made me think that this advantage might not be of interest of parents when they choose schools. On the contrary, some parents might deliberately try to avoid this diversity because they want their children to have peers who are similar to them.
ReplyDeleteAlthough it is commonly accepted that such diverisity in classroom would bring valuable personal experience and social skills to students, we can not prove that it is positively related to academic achievements, which is mostly valued by most parents.